How do clear aligners and braces work?
Braces (fixed orthodontic treatment) consist of small brackets bonded to the surface of the teeth and wires that run through these brackets. The wire applies a controlled force to the teeth, and at check-up appointments the dentist adjusts or changes the wire to move the teeth in the planned direction. The brackets can be metal or tooth-coloured (ceramic).
Clear aligners, as the British Orthodontic Society defines them, are thin, clear, flexible plastic trays that fit tightly over the teeth. Treatment is not done with a single aligner but with a series of aligners, each moving the teeth a little further than the one before. The aligners move the teeth step by step into their new positions according to the treatment plan prepared by the dentist.
Both methods have the same aim: to bring the teeth and the bite into a healthier, better-matched position. The differences lie in how they are used, which movements they are more effective for and what they expect of the patient.
When might clear aligners be suitable?
According to the British Orthodontic Society, clear aligners work well for mild to moderate problems with tooth alignment and are particularly suitable for adults who do not want to wear visible braces because of their lifestyle or work. The same source says additional techniques or different methods may be needed in the following situations:
- Severe crowding
- Treatment that requires extractions
- Problems caused by a difference in the size or position of the upper and lower jaws
The society also stresses that an accurate orthodontic assessment, diagnosis and treatment plan are essential for successful aligner treatment. In other words, the decision should be based on what the mouth actually needs, not only on the wish for something that does not show.
How does research compare the two methods?
A systematic review and meta-analysis by Ke and colleagues, published in BMC Oral Health in 2019, brought together studies comparing clear aligners with fixed braces. The authors’ conclusions can be summarised as follows:
- Both methods are effective in treating problems with tooth alignment and the bite.
- Clear aligners were found to have an advantage in moving teeth in segments, and the average treatment time was shorter in the studies examined.
- Braces were found to be more effective at achieving adequate contact between the teeth (the bite), controlling the angle of the tooth roots (torque) and maintaining the result after treatment.
- One of the studies reported more relapse in tooth alignment in patients treated with clear aligners.
These results are averages. Because the problems of the patients being compared may differ, the findings on treatment time cannot be used to predict how long one person’s treatment will take.
What are the differences in daily life?
| Point | Clear aligners | Braces |
|---|---|---|
| Visibility | Hard to notice unless you look closely | Metal brackets are visible; tooth-coloured brackets are less noticeable |
| Removability | Taken out for eating and brushing | Fixed; not removed until treatment ends |
| Eating and drinking | Few food restrictions, because the aligners are taken out; drinks other than water are usually drunk with the aligners out | Hard and sticky foods can damage the brackets |
| Oral care | The aligners can be taken out and the teeth brushed normally; the aligners also need cleaning | Cleaning around the brackets and wires takes more time |
| Patient’s responsibility | Treatment goes off track if they are not worn 20 to 22 hours a day | Because they are fixed, wearing time does not depend on the patient |
The NHS recommends brushing with fluoride toothpaste in the morning, at night and after meals while wearing braces, and cleaning between the teeth and under the wire every day with interdental brushes. The same source advises avoiding too many sugary foods and drinks, as they can cause tooth decay. This advice applies to both methods; with clear aligners, having sugary drinks while the aligners are in can trap liquid between the aligner and the teeth.
How long does treatment take?
According to the NHS, fixed braces usually stay on for 1 to 2 years. With clear aligners, the duration also depends on how regularly the patient wears the aligners. If the aligners are not worn for the recommended time, the teeth may not move as planned and the plan may have to be revised. We explain this in more detail in our guides how long do braces take? and how many hours a day should clear aligners be worn?
Is retention needed after treatment?
Yes, with both methods. According to the NHS, a retainer is worn after braces are removed to stop the teeth moving back; the orthodontist decides how long it should be worn. The British Orthodontic Society also says a retainer is needed after clear aligner treatment for the teeth to keep their corrected positions. Your dentist decides how long retention will last and how it will be followed up. See our guide to retention after orthodontic treatment for details.
What questions should you ask when deciding?
Getting answers to these questions at the examination helps you make an informed choice between the two methods:
- Is my problem mild, moderate or severe?
- Does treatment require extractions?
- Is there a jaw-related mismatch in my bite?
- Does my routine allow me to wear aligners for 20 to 22 hours a day?
- How often will check-ups be?
- How will the retention period after treatment be planned?
- Who will plan and carry out the treatment?
How is an orthodontic assessment carried out at Rönesans?
Orthodontics is one of the areas of treatment at Rönesans Diş Hekimliği. The current position of the teeth can be recorded with an intraoral scanner; when needed, three-dimensional imaging is carried out with the cone-beam CT (CBCT) scanner at the practice. The practice is open Monday to Friday from 10:00 to 22:00 and on Saturday from 10:00 to 19:00 (Türkiye time), so check-ups can be arranged outside school and working hours.
Both methods take months and need regular check-ups. We do not offer clear aligner treatment to patients travelling from abroad, because its check-ups cannot be kept from a distance; if you live outside Türkiye, ask us before you decide how check-ups for any orthodontic treatment would work. You can call +90 264 606 09 43, message us on WhatsApp (+90 532 363 49 54) or write to us through our contact page. For how aligner treatment works at our practice, see our clear aligners page, and for other options, including braces, our orthodontics page.