Home whitening or in-office whitening? What are the differences?

Written by: Dt. Muhammed Raşid KızılarslanoğluMedically reviewed by: Dt. Muhammed Raşid KızılarslanoğluUpdated:
In short

In research, dentist-supervised home whitening with custom trays and in-office whitening have produced similar colour change and similar sensitivity; the difference lies mainly in duration and method. Over-the-counter products from shops and online contain less active ingredient and should not be used without asking a dentist. The suitable method is decided at the examination.

What does “home whitening” actually mean?

In everyday language, “home whitening” is used for two very different things. MouthHealthy, the American Dental Association’s (ADA) patient website, divides whitening into three groups:

  • In-office whitening: carried out by the dentist, in the dental chair.
  • Dentist-supervised home whitening: the dentist has a custom tray made for you and decides on the gel and how long to use it; you carry out the whitening at home.
  • Over-the-counter products: strips, gels and toothpastes sold in shops and online. According to MouthHealthy, the whitening agent in these is weaker than the one dentists use.

In this guide, unless stated otherwise, “home whitening” means dentist-supervised home whitening. You can find a short comparison table of the three options in our guide does teeth whitening damage your teeth?

How is in-office whitening done?

According to MouthHealthy, whitening in the dental chair is usually completed in one visit: the dentist first protects the gums with a gel or a rubber barrier and then applies the whitening agent to the teeth. The ADA says that with this method, concentrated hydrogen peroxide solutions can be applied for up to 30 minutes, with or without a light.

How long the session takes depends on the method. The Oral Health Foundation says the treatment in the practice usually takes about an hour and that a special light may be used to support the process. According to the NHS, laser-assisted whitening is done in one appointment of about 1 to 2 hours; the gums are covered with a soft guard or paste, and you may be given tinted glasses for your eyes.

The main advantages of in-office whitening are:

  • The whole treatment is carried out under the dentist’s supervision; protecting the gums is not left to you.
  • You do not need to wear trays every day.
  • The change in colour is seen quickly.

How is dentist-supervised home whitening done?

According to patient information from Bristol Dental School, the process goes like this:

  1. Impressions of the teeth are taken, and clear trays that fit the teeth exactly are made.
  2. After brushing, a small amount of gel is put into the tray where it will sit against the front surface of each tooth to be whitened.
  3. The tray is put in, and any gel that spills over onto the gums is wiped off.
  4. The trays are worn for at least two hours; most patients wear them overnight.
  5. The trays are rinsed after use.

The colour starts to lighten gradually within a few days. The sources give different ranges for the total time: in a systematic review cited by the ADA, daily wear ranged from 2 to 10 hours and the total treatment time from 6 to 28 days. The NHS says about 2 to 6 weeks, and the Oral Health Foundation usually 1 to 2 weeks. According to the ADA, the most important factor in the duration is the concentration of the gel; for darkening caused by tetracycline, treatment with overnight wear can take three to four months on average.

The main advantages of home whitening are:

  • The treatment fits around your daily life and is often done while you sleep.
  • The colour lightens gradually; according to Bristol Dental School, the treatment is continued until the desired shade is reached.
  • According to the Oral Health Foundation, the trays can be kept and reused in the future.

In return, it is up to you to wear the trays regularly for the recommended time. The ADA says gum irritation is often caused by trays that do not fit well or by gel not being applied correctly.

Which is more effective, and which causes more sensitivity?

Two reviews that brought together studies on this question reached similar results:

  • de Geus and colleagues (2016): in this systematic review published in Operative Dentistry, no significant difference in colour change was found between dentist-supervised home whitening and in-office whitening. The risk and severity of sensitivity were also similar with both methods.
  • Aidos and colleagues (2024): in this umbrella review published in Heliyon, which examined 28 systematic reviews, no difference was seen between the two methods in colour change or sensitivity either. According to the authors, sensitivity can occur with either method, regardless of the technique used.

These results need to be interpreted with care. De Geus and colleagues note that the comparison did not take account of differences in protocol, such as daily wearing time, number of sessions and gel concentration, and that the differences between studies were large. The quality of the reviews examined by Aidos and colleagues also ranged from very low to high. In practice, this means that when done under a dentist’s supervision with a suitable protocol, both methods can give similar results; the choice often depends on your circumstances.

Which method may suit whom?

The decision is made at the examination, but the following questions can help you think about which way you lean:

  • Will you be able to wear the trays regularly every day? The result of home whitening depends on wearing the trays for the recommended time. If keeping up this routine seems difficult, in-office whitening may be more practical.
  • Have you had sensitivity before? According to the ADA, sensitivity tends to increase as the concentration of the active ingredient rises. Mentioning your history of sensitivity at the examination affects the choice of gel and duration.
  • What is causing the discolouration? According to MouthHealthy, yellowish tones usually respond well, while greyish tones may not lighten with whitening. With darkening caused by medicines, whitening can take a very long time or may not give a satisfactory result; for darkening of a single root-filled tooth, a different method carried out from inside the tooth may be considered.
  • Do you have fillings, crowns or veneers on your front teeth? According to the Oral Health Foundation, whitening does not change their colour; with both methods, colour matching is planned separately.
  • Are your teeth and gums healthy? The NHS says a dentist should check that your teeth and gums are healthy before whitening. The ADA also recommends that the cause of the discolouration is identified at the examination, with X-rays if necessary.

We explain who should postpone whitening on our teeth whitening page.

What warnings are there about products from shops and online?

In Türkiye: according to the guideline of the Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency (TİTCK) on cosmetic products for professional use, under the Cosmetics Regulation, oral and dental care products that contain or release more than 0.1% and up to 6% hydrogen peroxide are intended for special use and may only be sold to dentists. The first application of each course of use is carried out by the dentist; if the dentist considers it appropriate, the product may then be given to the person to complete the course. These products are not suitable for use by under-18s. The same guideline also states that businesses providing oral and dental care must comply with the legislation on dentistry.

Other warnings in the sources:

  • NHS: home kits from a pharmacy or online, and whitening done in beauty salons, are less effective and may harm your teeth and gums.
  • Oral Health Foundation: strips, gels and paint-on products sold in shops contain very little whitening agent; although they may reduce some surface stains, they usually do not change the natural colour of the tooth much and are no substitute for whitening by a dentist. The foundation stresses that in the United Kingdom, whitening may only be carried out by registered dental professionals, and that treatment by untrained people can cause permanent damage to the teeth and gums.
  • ADA: over-the-counter products contain lower levels of peroxide and take longer to work; in a study it cites, an over-the-counter method took 16 days to reach the result of seven days of home whitening with trays.
  • MouthHealthy: recommends talking to a dentist before buying an over-the-counter product and, if you use one, following the instructions exactly; overuse can damage the enamel and gums.

With treatments carried out without a dental examination, the cause of the discolouration is not assessed; whitening may be tried without noticing a decayed tooth, an old filling or a root-filled tooth. The risks of home remedies such as lemon, baking soda and activated charcoal are explained in our guide does teeth whitening damage your teeth?

How is the whitening method chosen at Rönesans?

Before whitening, we assess at the examination the condition of your teeth and gums, any existing fillings and crowns, and the cause of the discolouration. Plaque and surface stains are cleaned off first; at our practice, this cleaning can be done with a device that sprays a mixture of air, water and fine powder onto the tooth surface. For some patients, the teeth already look lighter after cleaning, and expectations are discussed again. We decide together at the examination which method suits you, taking your history of sensitivity and your expectations into account. If home whitening is planned, the impressions needed for the custom trays can be taken with an intraoral scanner.

If you are visiting from abroad, whitening at our practice is done in-office, in the dental chair, so that it fits into your stay rather than continuing at home after you leave. If you are also having crowns or veneers, the order of treatment and the length of your stay are discussed at the examination; our page on planning your visit gives a general guide.

Follow-up after treatment runs as a defined process at our practice. We give you the treatment and cost plan in writing; the cost is confirmed after the examination, based on the treatment plan. To arrange an appointment, you can call +90 264 606 09 43 Monday to Friday from 10:00 to 22:00 and on Saturday from 10:00 to 19:00 (Türkiye time), message us on WhatsApp at +90 532 363 49 54 or write to us through our contact page; we answer messages in English and German within 15 minutes during opening hours. For methods and stages, see our teeth whitening page, and for planning the colour and shape of the front teeth, our smile makeover page.

Sources
  1. Profesyonel Kullanım Amaçlı Kozmetik Ürünlere İlişkin Kılavuz, Sürüm 1.0 – Türkiye İlaç ve Tıbbi Cihaz Kurumu (TİTCK)
  2. Teeth whitening – NHS
  3. Whitening – American Dental Association (ADA), Oral Health Topics
  4. Teeth Whitening – MouthHealthy, American Dental Association
  5. Tooth whitening – Oral Health Foundation
  6. Tooth whitening – Bristol Dental School, University of Bristol
  7. de Geus JL, Wambier LM, Kossatz S, Loguercio AD, Reis A. At-home vs In-office Bleaching: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Operative Dentistry, 2016;41(4):341–356.
  8. Aidos M, Marto CM, Amaro I ve ark. Comparison of in-office and at-home bleaching techniques: An umbrella review of efficacy and post-operative sensitivity. Heliyon, 2024;10(3):e25833.

Frequently asked questions

Is in-office whitening finished in one session?

One session is often enough, but in some cases more than one is planned. MouthHealthy, the American Dental Association's patient website, says in-office whitening usually takes one visit. The number of sessions needed is decided at the examination according to the type of discolouration and your sensitivity.

Should I wear home whitening trays overnight?

This depends on the gel your dentist recommends and how long it should be used. Bristol Dental School recommends wearing the trays for at least two hours and says most patients wear them overnight. Do not extend the wearing time on your own.

Are whitening products from shops and online freely available in Türkiye?

According to the guideline of the Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency, oral and dental care products containing or releasing more than 0.1% and up to 6% hydrogen peroxide may only be sold to dentists. Products sold freely have a limited whitening effect; it is advisable to ask your dentist before using them.

Which method causes less sensitivity?

Reviews that bring the research together found no significant difference in sensitivity between the two methods. The American Dental Association says sensitivity tends to increase as the concentration of the active ingredient rises. If you have had sensitivity before, mentioning it at the examination affects the choice of method and gel.

Can under-18s have their teeth whitened?

It is generally not recommended. According to the guideline of the Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency (TİTCK), products containing 0.1% to 6% hydrogen peroxide are not suitable for use by under-18s; the NHS also says whitening is not done for people aged 17 and under. In young people, the cause of the colour problem and suitable options are assessed at the examination.

Find out at an examination whether this treatment suits you

Send us photos or X-rays on WhatsApp for a preliminary assessment. Your final plan is made after an in-person examination.

Related pages

This page is general information. A personal assessment requires an examination by a dentist.